The following are comments from the U.S.
readers at the book's
amazon.com Web site:
A New Perspective - I found
this book to be a much clearer description of my symptoms and behaviors
than previous books I've read. Dr. Mate touches on areas that I have
intuitively thought played a role in my behavior, that have not been
discussed elsewhere. My wife thought he had written my biography. This
book discusses a theory regarding the cause of ADD and has provided me
with the clearest explanation and understanding of my experiences with
ADD that I have been able to find. I also found the discussions of
motivation, self-esteem, and anxiety to be extremely helpful. This book
will not provide the reader with all the solutions one might be looking
for, but it may offer an explanation that one has not seen before.
~Patrick from Madison, WI
Now You Will Understand the
Cause of Attention Deficit Disorder - This phenomenal book,
Scattered, by Dr. Gabor Mate, goes beyond causing us to totally rethink
anything we thought we knew about Attention Deficit Disorder. Dr. Mate
introduces us to an eye- opening concept that the cause of ADD is that
children (he explains that it's due to what is called a lack of
attunement between parent and child) are often not registering and
processing the love of even the most caring parents. The author does a
masterful job of explaining why this is so. Suddenly, one appreciates
just how much knowledge and awareness must go in to the complex job of
parenting. Dr. Mate truly has a gift for sharing this information in a
way that will mesmerize readers of this inspiring book. After reading
Scattered, many will no doubt come to the realization that they, or
someone they love, may suffer from ADD or Adult ADD. I owe Dr. Mate a
debt of gratitude for clarifying why so many people are experiencing
such hurt and pain. Needless to say, I recommend this book as being
crucially important for anyone who has reached a point of desperation in
terms of understanding the cause of their emotional problems. This book
should be mandatory reading for every teacher - for anyone who works
with children. Thank you, Dr. Mate for your intuitive insights and this
groundbreaking work that could change the world by impacting on all the
generations to come.
~ Amy Keehn from Portland, OR
Still learning after all these
years - I read this book when it first came out, I think my son was
5 at the time. I always kept the message, that the long term objective
was not symptom control or even behavior control, but development. That
is the book in a nutshell. Try to understand your child, and make his
development as a human being the most important thing...it's
extraordinarily hard and forces you to grow up as a parent and think of
your child first. Common sense that is not so common. And it is NOT a
quick solution. It was something my parents figured out a long time ago;
when some of my friends wanted to run away because of mistreatment as
teenagers, we always knew we had it too good. Understanding beats the
hell out of beatings...
Be forwarned, don't read this book unless you really want to be there
for your child...We all are guilty of being human and making millions of
mistakes, and most kids are easy to raise in compared to the "sensitive"
child. This book just asks you to be compassionate. It is so hard, but
so rewarding.
~Rose from Columbia, South Carolina United States
: "The best thing for being sad
is to learn something." - Having been in therapy longer than Woody
Allen, I practice what Karl Menninger called 'bibliotherapy'-i.e.,
reading widely and deeply in the field of mental or emotional disorders.
Since I'm a voracious reader, and since I've been doing this for twenty
years, I sometimes feel there isn't much left for a layman to learn, or
at least nothing much that could be called new. But Dr. Mate's book is
wonderfully helpful on two fronts: first, it is a "why-you-or-your
-child-are-like-this" book, and second, it is a
"and-here-is-what-you-can-do-to-allieviate-the-condition"book. Not cure
it, mind you, just make the cards you drew a little easier to play.
On the first front, the neurobiology of ADD, Dr. Mate makes his point
conclusively: this disorder arises first in the infant, in how he or she
is wired-or not-and it occurs in the make-up of the hypersensitive baby,
highly aware and from the very beginning suffering at the smallest
slings and arrows life offers. Resilient children roll with the punches;
ADD kids are flattened by them and get back up more slowly. Momma used
to call this type "high-strung" and, boy, was she ever right. Dr. Mate
even points out a study done on the vagus nerve of five-month old babies
that turns out to be highly predictive of which of them will later, at
fourteen months, prove to be "more reactive to maternal separation." In
other words, ADD could as well serve as an acronym for Attachment
Deficit Disorder. People who are hypersensitive have a disordered
attachment to their caretakers that is pre-verbal and pervasive. One had
better learn to deal with the fact that the fault is mainly synpatical,
not social. My family doctor told me that my then-nine-year-old son
suffered from severe separation anxiety because he hadn't been in
pre-school or away from his parents enough. Fortunately, a more
knowledgeable child psychiatrist said it was inborn so we could relax
and quit blaming ourselves. Whew....
That doesn't mean that experiencing this hypersensitivity isn't
damaging, even with a more-than-good-enough mother. Or that nurturing a
hypersensitive child is easy. It is much more tiring and trying to deal
with the ADD child than it is with his or her more resilient sibling.The
ADD child triggers anxiety in even the most competent parent. So, it is
on the second front, the practical things to do, that this book is most
helpful, even hopeful. I return to it again and again (that is, when I
haven't mislaid it in one of my more driven ADD moments) to remind
myself what to do and what not to do to help myself and my
similarly-wired son. For instance, the section on the counter-will-an
idea I'd not heard before-made me understand why I am more often than
not so suspicious of authority figures. I used to think it was very
adolescent of me, and now Dr. Mate tells me it is, and that this is a
component of ADD. It was from this notion of a counter-will that I began
my search on ways to strengthen the will itself, so as to disengage this
adversarial part of me, the counter-will, that aspect of us that doesn't
trust. It has been an interesting and fruitful search and I am grateful
to Dr. Mate for giving me new ways to think about this way of being in
the world.
By the time the ADD child arrives at school, the disconnectedness is
ingrained. We are attuned to every slight, intended or not. Other kids
find ADDers just as trying as the grown-ups do-it takes a lot of energy
to interact with a 'wild child' who hogs the teacher's attention or a
distracted one whose hypersensitivity presents the perfect opportunity
to torture for fun and profit. I've yet to find an ADD adult who liked
the social aspects of school, or didn't have horror stories about cruel
peers and teachers...
The most important chapters for me have been the ones on medication
and on self-parenting. The first, medication, gives the limits of
pharmocological help for this disorder. It is very clear about what
medicine can and cannot do and the importance of finding a knowledgeable
physician. The second, self-parenting, seems like a Mobius strip until
Dr. Mate takes apart the results of life-time conditioning and explains
the qualities one needs-compassion for self and others, curiosity rather
than blame or judgment-in order to embark on a course of change. Whether
one has to structure things by herself, or has the good fortune to find
competent professional help, Dr. Mate's book is of inestimable help on
that journey.
In fact, every time my ADD tendencies pop up and I lose my copy of
Scattered, I buy another. And now that my stepson has been diagnosed
with ADD, I have an extra copy or two to give his suffering parents,
though I would not be without this book.
Scattered is definitely a keeper.
~ A Reader from Howardsville, VA USA
After all these Years- Every
once in a while, a book comes along that dramatically changes the way
you think. After all these years, just when I thought I read everything
there was to know about ADD, Dr. Gabor Mate writes such a compelling
book, that I must rethink what I have learned and stubbornly believed
about the origins and outcomes for children and adults with ADD. In the
Footprints of Infancy Chapter, I had an epiphany regarding my own life
and the lives of my children. As a school psychologist who works with
teachers, I have learned how to better meet the needs of children with
ADD in the classroom, and how to explain the power of a teacher to those
who work with these children. Read this book! It will give you the
knowledge, hope, and the tools to improve your life. Scattered will help
you understand your spouse, child and students.
~ Linda Halperin, Ed.S from Morristown NJ USA
Kind
and Insightful - I have read nearly everything out there on ADD, for many years.
Many of my family members, as well as myself, have ADD. I have also researched all related
subjects from neurology to chemistry to genetics. I must say this is the best book I've
read on the subject. Instead of vaguely listing traits and behavioral/rienforcement
"corrections", he delves deep into our emotions, deep into our past, and finds
the keys to the behaviors. You will find the journey fascinating. He discovers the tie of
inborn sensitivity to ADD, which was where my extensive research was leading me, also. He
separates the negative issues from the positive ones in ADD for the purpose of reassuring
us that to let go of the negative doesn't squash or choke the many positive aspects of a
person with ADD. This book will help you forgive a loved one with ADD for being confusing
and hurtful at times, and it will help you forgive yourself if you have ADD, with reality,
not theory. This book is no fluff. Gabor Mate, (a person with ADD himself) understands
ADD. I consider this a must-read.
~A reader from Vistas, California
Applauding Gabor Mate. I applaud
Gabor Mate for the remarkable contribution he has made to the literature on Attention
Deficit Disorder in his book Scattered. Due to both personal and professional
interest, I have read and recommended many books and articles on this topic. I find that Scattered
has become the first book I recommend to colleagues, clients and anyone interested in
learning about, or ruling out ADD. Feedback is consistent with my own reaction--this is a
comprehensive and insightful book--an easy, informative, valuable, read for professional
and lay people. The role of biology/nature is described so well that the non-scientific
reader gains a new level of understanding. When it comes to the role of
nurture/environment--Mate truly shines-- capturing the experience of ADD with an insiders
wisdom and a refreshing openness, bringing the reader understanding, comfort, hope and
pathways to healing. The material on parenting (ADD and the child) is excellent---could be
part of a parenting handbook. His writing on change and growth and his understanding of
what causes adults to struggle have value across the board --whatever the issues are. One
does not have to have, or work with ADD to enjoy and benefit from Scattered.
~ M.Burke LCSW from New Jersey
Finally, the answers! Do
you wonder why you do and feel all of the weird things you do and feel? If it's due to
Attention Deficit Disorder, you'll be thrilled with this compassionate, user-friendly
book. Dr. Mate is personal, clear, and non-blaming in his explanations, insights, and
suggestions for healing. His approach to medication usage is conservative but balanced. He
and several of his children have ADD, and he shares honestly about his struggles with the
symptoms. The book offers an excellent tapestry of the neurological and the psychological.
I found that I now had an understanding of the "neurology behind the
psychology."
~ Nancy Guenther (see more about me) from Illinois
[TOP]
An insightful, humane perspective.
The ADHD world seems to have split into several definable camps -- the neo-Darwinist
doomsayers like Barkley who say flat-out that ADD is "of no value whatsoever"
and is purely a sickness; the deniers like Breggin and Rush Limbaugh who think it's a
conspiracy by doctors or liberals; the geneticists like Comings who suggest ADDers
shouldn't breed to keep from contaminating our gene-pool; and those like Lucy Jo Pallidino
who consider it a "context disorder," a collection of traits that may be useful
in some times and places but is generally not a good match for the way our schools are
currently set up (I consider myself in this category).
Now comes Gabor Mate, an insightful, no-nonsense, and thoroughly compassionate
physician who provides an overview of all these perspectives and comes to the marvelously
humane conclusion that ADD/ADHD is neither nature (genetics) nor nurture
(parenting/environment) but, rather, the result of the collision of a predisposing nature
with an ADD-hostile life situation, family, school, or job. How refreshing!
Gabor Mate has made a valuable contribution to the ADD/ADHD world, and this book not
only offers thoughts on what it is and where it came from, but also is chock full of
useful, real-world solutions for the problems people with ADD confront in a world
increasingly run by bureaucrats and farmers.
Highly recommended!
~
Thom Hartmann
[TOP]
Reading this book was the best thing that ever
happened to me. For me as a 49-years-old with only recently diagnosed ADD, it is of more
therapeutic value than a good 17 years of psychotherapy have been. One reason is that I
feel understood for the first time in my life. Another reason is formed by Maté's clear
explanations on how to treat myself in order to make room for personal growth and
development. In short: a jewel.
~ B.J. van Kesteren from The Netherlands
Dr. Mate writes a book that is both informative and
from the heart. As 43 year old adult female, recently attempting to negotiate the
challenging journey of being assessed for ADD, I found the book both validating and
hopeful with very practical information about the next steps once the diagnosis is made.
The book goes beyond the stereotype of the hyperactive child or dysfunctional
underachieving adult to give a more accurate view of the many ways ADD can manifest in
adults and children. He also is very realistic about what medications can and can not do.
I highly recommend this book to anyone who has ADD, may think they are ADD, has a child,
student or significant other with ADD. There is clear concise information for each of
these audiences. Thank you Dr. Gabor for such a wonderful book!
~ A reader from the United States
[TOP]
This is a must read if your child has ADD.
This is the only book I've found on ADD that actually explains -- in concrete terms -- the
science behind ADD symptoms outside of a obligatory chapter. And I think the advice on
parenting is practical and feasible -- moreover, Mate shares his mistakes and lets us
learn from them.
~ A reader from Seattle
Excellent book. Give it as a gift! A
wonderful book on the insights of ADD. Helpful for Parents who really want to understand
what their child is going through with ADD. How you can help your child cope better with
with this problem, and how you can help improve your child.
~ A reader from Washington, U.S.A
[TOP]
An excellent, well researched book. Highly
recommended. Dr. Mate, who has ADD himself and who is the father of three
children with ADD, provides information about brain development and theorizes that ADD
results from problems in bonding that effect brain development. He discusses addiction as
related to ADD and the lack of bonding. He provides a method of treatment that addresses
the underlying dynamic rather than dealing more superficially. As someone with ADD myself,
experience in working with autistic and learning disabled children, and a strong interest
in curative emotional relationships, I have found this book incredibly insightful and
useful. It is strongly recommended to professionals as well as clients and families. It is
written with respect and compassion and refrains from blaming parents for their children's
difficulties.
~ A reader from the United States
A provocative book that offers insights and
hope. SCATTERED is filled with insights into possible origins of A.D.D.
in early-life contexts. I found Dr. Mate's research very helpful in uncovering these
origins in myself. One of my main problems as an artist is focusing long enough on one
creative project to actually accomplish it. By pinpointing possible origins in myself I am
dissolving negative energy investments. I seek daily to re-gather this energy & to
apply it to creative projects for a more fulfilling life. Also, I use the material in SCATTERED
to enrich dwelling on the Earth by un-focusing on what is not important & discovering
what is. Thank you & Good Luck!
~ Gary Clark, Clearwater Beach, Florida
[TOP] |